Sanctuary compared with Tithely

A Tithely alternative for churches that want operations to start with people

Tithely offers a wide set of tools for giving, administration and engagement. Sanctuary starts with a free database of people and households, then a paid plan adds scheduling, service planning and giving, with check-in and Shepherd on the larger plans.

Competitor information reviewed from first-party sources on .

The practical difference

How to think about Sanctuary and Tithely

Tithely is more than a staff database. It combines giving with communication and with apps and websites for your congregation. If you want all of that from one company, it can mean fewer vendors. It can also duplicate a website, streaming provider or communication system you have no reason to replace.

Sanctuary makes more sense when you want your staff work, your website and your congregation app all running from the same records. Giving also works differently. Your church runs its own connected Stripe account, and Sanctuary links the gifts to people, funds, reports and statements.

An honest comparison

When Tithely may be the better choice

  • You want small groups managed by the same company as your giving, app and website.
  • Your giving depends on kiosk giving, tap to give, or Tithely’s shared Giving App.
  • You want group chat for your congregation, and a long-established engagement suite alongside giving.
  • Having background checks and training from the same company is important to how you work.

Consider Sanctuary

When Sanctuary may fit your church better

  • You want people, families, forms, events, registrations, tasks and follow-up to stay free, with no limit on people.
  • The admin system is your priority, and you’d rather have your website and congregation app built from the same records than buy them separately.
  • You want donations processed through your church’s own connected Stripe account, with the actual fees tracked and statements tied to the same records.
  • You’d rather start free with people records, then move to one plan for scheduling, giving and your app when your church is ready.
  • You want a congregation app included in your plan, where families give, register for events and keep their household up to date.

Before you switch

Questions to answer with your team

  • Do you need a custom church app and website, or would they duplicate tools your church already likes?
  • Which ways of giving do your donors actually use: web, recurring, text, kiosk, tap or a shared mobile app?
  • How much of your decision is about the donor experience, and how much is about staff work and clean people data?
  • Which records, recurring gifts, statements, groups and messaging consent records have to move safely?

Migration

A safer way to evaluate the move

  • List every Tithely product you use, including the app, website, messaging, giving, groups and check-in.
  • Work out which features you need to replace and which are already covered by another vendor you trust.
  • Plan the move of recurring gifts and donor history with your finance team before you announce a new way to give.
  • Test consent, contact preferences, household matching, statements and year-to-date totals before you launch.

Sanctuary is not affiliated with Tithely. Product names and trademarks belong to their respective owners.