Sanctuary compared with Breeze

A Breeze alternative now that Breeze is Tithely Church Management

Breeze is known for being easy to use, and its website now says Breeze ChMS has been rebranded as Tithely Church Management. Sanctuary is newer. Its people and household database is free, and a paid plan adds scheduling, service planning and giving, with check-in and Shepherd on the larger plans.

Competitor information reviewed from first-party sources on .

The practical difference

How to think about Sanctuary and Breeze

A lot of churches picked Breeze because volunteers and part-time staff could learn it in an afternoon. That’s a real strength, and the rebrand doesn’t change it. Breeze is now presented as a Tithe.ly company, with Tithely apps and websites offered alongside it. The name on the login page has changed. What matters is whether the software you use every week still works for your church.

Sanctuary is worth a look if you want your people database to cost nothing on its own, or you want volunteer schedules, service plans, giving and check-in to work from the same household records. It’s harder to justify if Breeze is working well and your team cares more about familiar screens than new features. Switching takes staff time, and an easy tool everyone already knows is worth a lot.

An honest comparison

When Breeze may be the better choice

  • Your staff and volunteers already know Breeze, and its simplicity is why you picked it.
  • You want one plan that lists giving, text giving, texting, check-in and name tags, events, a member directory, a mobile app and service planning.
  • You’re interested in other Tithely products from the same company, like Tithely Church Apps and Tithely Sites.
  • Phone and email support with your account matters more to you than any difference in features.

Consider Sanctuary

When Sanctuary may fit your church better

  • You want people and household records, forms, event registration, the calendar and tasks to stay free, with no limit on people and no card on file.
  • You want volunteer scheduling, service plans, songs and stage displays in Serve, using the same people your office already keeps track of.
  • You want gifts charged on your church’s own Stripe account, which the church owns and can log into, and giving statements built from the same records.
  • You want Shepherd, Sanctuary’s assistant that follows each person’s permissions, to help with routine admin on the plans that include it.
  • You want Move to Sanctuary to recognize a Breeze people export, keep each person’s Breeze ID and rebuild families before anything is saved.

Before you switch

Questions to answer with your team

  • Has the move to Tithely Church Management changed anything for your church yet? Ask Tithely directly instead of assuming either way.
  • Which Breeze features do you use every week, and which are turned on but never used?
  • How much do you rely on Breeze tags and groups? Sanctuary has custom fields, lists and live sheets, but no dedicated small-groups product.
  • If you move giving, how will recurring givers set up their gifts again, and who will tell them before the switch?

Migration

A safer way to evaluate the move

  • Choose the Breeze option in Move to Sanctuary. It tells you which Breeze people export to run, reads the file as Excel or CSV, and maps the columns, including Breeze ID and Family ID.
  • Before you import, turn Breeze tags into Sanctuary custom fields or lists, so you can find the same people the same way afterward.
  • Bring in contribution history as a giving file with one gift per row (date, amount and fund). Then reconcile the fund totals with your treasurer.
  • Moving in with Move to Sanctuary comes with paid plans, so check your plan first. Move people records before giving and check-in, and don’t do them on the same weekend.