Sanctuary compared with Pushpay
A Pushpay alternative for churches that want a lighter connected system
Pushpay combines giving, engagement, apps, church management, reporting and a large set of integrations. Sanctuary is for churches that want a simpler start: free people management, with scheduling, service planning, giving, check-in and Shepherd connected to it.
Competitor information reviewed from first-party sources on .
The practical difference
How to think about Sanctuary and Pushpay
Pushpay describes itself as a platform for engagement and generosity as well as church management software. For a large organization, its mobile app, integrations, reporting and enterprise experience may be exactly what you want. A decision to replace it shouldn’t come down to comparing a handful of feature checkboxes.
Sanctuary is a more natural fit for a small or mid-sized church that mainly needs its staff working from up-to-date people, schedules, plans, gifts and check-in records. That’s a deliberate tradeoff. Sanctuary doesn’t claim to replace Pushpay’s full set of engagement tools and integrations.
An honest comparison
When Pushpay may be the better choice
- Your congregation app is central to how you engage people, and you want the analytics and engagement tools Pushpay builds around it.
- You need a wide range of integrations because you plan to keep several of your current systems.
- You’re a large or complex organization looking for an established giving and engagement company with enterprise experience.
- You’d rather have guided analysis, demos and a vendor-led rollout than set things up yourself.
Consider Sanctuary
When Sanctuary may fit your church better
- You want to begin with free people and household management, instead of committing to a broad engagement suite first.
- Your main problems are staff work: records, forms, events, volunteer schedules, service plans, giving and check-in.
- You want giving charged directly to your church’s own Stripe account, with the actual processing fees recorded.
- You want to start small and add more over time, which suits a small or mid-sized church without much time for setup.
- You want a congregation app included in your plan, built from the same records your staff keep. A church website comes with Complete and up.
Before you switch
Questions to answer with your team
- Do you need an app under your church’s own name, or would a shared congregation app do the job?
- Which integrations can’t you do without, and could one connected system remove some of them?
- How much onboarding, implementation help, reporting and scale do you need?
- Can each vendor show your real giving, scheduling, check-in and statement workflows using data like yours?
Migration
A safer way to evaluate the move
- List every integration and which system holds the main record on each side of it.
- Confirm how recurring gifts, saved payment methods, donor history and statements can be moved over.
- While you evaluate, test real situations for multiple campuses, permissions, reporting and reconciliation.
- Roll it out in stages, so staff work and the way donors give don’t change on the same weekend.
Continue evaluating Sanctuary
Sources checked
Sanctuary is not affiliated with Pushpay. Product names and trademarks belong to their respective owners.