Sanctuary compared with ChurchTrac
A ChurchTrac alternative, starting with where you keep your books
ChurchTrac is an independent, privately owned church management system that has served churches since 2002. One subscription includes fund accounting, giving, check-in, worship planning, a website and an app. Sanctuary is a newer system that doesn’t do accounting. People management is free, and a paid plan adds scheduling and giving, with check-in and Shepherd on the larger plans.
Competitor information reviewed from first-party sources on .
The practical difference
How to think about Sanctuary and ChurchTrac
Before you compare features, figure out where your church keeps its books. ChurchTrac includes fund accounting, bank sync, budgets, and reports like a balance sheet and income statement. Sanctuary has no general ledger, bank sync or budgeting. If your treasurer works in ChurchTrac’s accounting every week, moving to Sanctuary means you’d need a separate accounting system too, and that may not be worth it.
Online giving shouldn’t decide it either way. ChurchTrac’s giving runs through Stripe, and its site says it takes no revenue share on gifts. Sanctuary also charges gifts on the church’s own Stripe account. Sanctuary makes more sense if your accounting already lives somewhere else and you want a free, unlimited people database with volunteer scheduling, service planning and administration built around it.
An honest comparison
When ChurchTrac may be the better choice
- You want fund accounting, bank sync, budgets and financial reports in the same system as your contributions.
- You want fund accounting in the same subscription as your website, app and member portal. ChurchTrac calls the public side Church Connect.
- You want child check-in with unlimited kiosks and security labels on Brother label printers, included with every subscription.
- You value a long-running independent company with a US-based support team, free one-on-one workshops and live training.
Consider Sanctuary
When Sanctuary may fit your church better
- You want people and households, forms, event registration, the calendar, tasks and custom fields free, with no limit on how many people you keep.
- Your books are already in a separate accounting system, and you want church software that focuses on people and ministry work.
- You want volunteer scheduling, service plans, songs and stage displays in Serve, connected to the same people records.
- You want Shepherd to help staff with routine admin, with what it can see limited by each person’s permissions.
- You want to send email newsletters, texts and printed letters from the same people records, without exporting a list.
Before you switch
Questions to answer with your team
- Who keeps the books today, and in which system? If it’s ChurchTrac Accounting, what will you use instead?
- Does your congregation use the ChurchTrac website, app or member portal? Would replacing them be welcome or a hassle?
- How is child check-in set up today, including printers and kiosks? Sanctuary Check-Ins is in early access and gets turned on church by church, so make sure it fits before you plan around it.
- Which reports does your finance team need each year, and can each system produce them from your real data?
Migration
A safer way to evaluate the move
- Export people and families as a spreadsheet. Move to Sanctuary doesn’t have a ChurchTrac preset, so choose Something else, keep a family ID column, and check each column mapping yourself.
- Decide where accounting will live before you move any giving. Keep both systems readable until your year-end statements are done.
- Bring in contribution history with one gift per row (date, amount and fund). Then compare each fund’s totals with ChurchTrac’s reports.
- Move the public website and app on their own schedule, separate from staff records, giving and check-in.
Continue evaluating Sanctuary
Sanctuary is not affiliated with ChurchTrac. Product names and trademarks belong to their respective owners.