Church management

How to follow up with first-time church visitors, with templates

Following up with a first-time guest comes down to a few short, personal messages sent soon after they visit, and then someone who gets to know them. This guide has the guest card, who should own follow-up, a three-week timeline, five templates you can copy, and how to keep it from feeling like spam.

The Sanctuary teamSanctuary9 min read

What should guest follow-up look like?

A first-time guest should hear from your church the same day they visit. By midweek, they should hear from a real person. Within two weeks, offer them one clear next step. After that, introduce them to someone who’ll get to know them. That’s four or five contacts over about three weeks. You don’t need a long automated email series.

Most follow-up doesn’t happen because nobody’s in charge of it. The cards sit in a basket until Thursday, the person who meant to call gets sick, and by the next Sunday it’s too late. Write down who does each step. Once that’s settled, the templates below are the easy part.

What to ask on the guest card

Most churches need two forms. A Plan a Visit form on your website lets people tell you they’re coming, so someone can meet them at the door and the kids’ rooms are ready. A first-time guest card, on paper or through a QR code, is for everyone who just shows up.

Only ask for what you’ll actually use in the next three weeks:

  • First and last name, and the best way to reach them: email, mobile number or both.
  • Whether it’s OK to text them. A phone number on its own isn’t permission to text, so give this its own checkbox with clear wording.
  • How they heard about the church. It’s useful to know, and it gives you something real to mention when you welcome them.
  • Next steps they can check: learn more about faith, join a group, talk with a pastor, serve, kids’ ministry.
  • An optional prayer request. This goes to a pastor or the prayer team, never onto a newsletter list.
  • For Plan a Visit: which Sunday they’re coming, how many people, and whether they’re bringing kids and how old they are.

Leave off anything that feels like a membership interview, like date of birth, marital status, giving history, home church or “are you saved?” If you wouldn’t ask it over coffee with someone you just met, don’t put it on the card. Make every field optional except their name and one way to reach them.

Who owns follow-up

Pick one person to own the whole process. In a small church, that might be a volunteer instead of a pastor. They don’t have to make every contact themselves. Their job is to make sure every guest gets every step, and to notice when one gets missed.

  • The owner enters or checks every card by noon on Monday and sends or approves the same-day welcome.
  • A pastor or elder writes the midweek personal note.
  • When a guest checks a ministry’s box, that ministry’s leader takes it from there. The groups leader handles groups, and the kids’ director handles families with children.
  • Have a backup owner for holidays and sick weeks. If follow-up depends on one person, it stops the week they’re away.

A day-by-day timeline for the first three weeks

Guest follow-up timeline (Day 0 is the first visit)
WhenWhat happensWho
Before the visitIf they used Plan a Visit: a reply confirming the Sunday, where to park, and who’ll meet them.Owner or host team
Day 0, same dayA short welcome text (if they said yes to texts) or email. Just say thanks. Don’t ask for anything.Owner
Day 1Enter and check the cards. Pass prayer requests to a pastor. Send each next-step box to the right leader.Owner
Day 2–3A personal note from a pastor, either a handwritten card or a short personal email.Pastor
Day 3–6Anyone who checked a next step hears directly from that ministry’s leader.Ministry leader
Day 7–10One invitation to one specific next step that fits them.Owner or leader
Day 14–21If they haven’t been back, one “we’d love to see you again” message. Then stop.Owner
Day 21Wrap it up: introduce them to someone, add them to a general update only if they asked for it, or mark their follow-up as finished.Owner

Five templates you can copy

Fill in the brackets, keep them short, and sign with a real first name. Change the wording until it sounds like your church. If a message still reads like a template, a plain sentence in your own words is better.

1. Same-day welcome text (only if they said yes to texts):

2. Same-day welcome email:

3. Midweek personal note from a pastor (handwritten or email):

4. Invitation to one next step (Day 7–10):

5. “We missed you” (Day 14–21, sent once):

These leave a few things out on purpose. There’s no list of every ministry, no giving link, no newsletter sign-up and no “we noticed you haven’t been back.” Each message does one thing, and it’s easy for the guest not to reply.

Introduce them to someone

By the end of the three weeks, you want the guest to know someone besides the person doing follow-up. Once they’ve come back, replied or taken a next step, introduce them by name to a host, a group leader or a family around their age, and tell that person what the guest shared. Then write down that you made the introduction. If nobody writes it down, nobody will check that it happened.

What to keep track of, and how not to spam people

You don’t need a dashboard. For each guest, you just need to know when they first came, which step they’re on, who’s doing the next step, whether they replied and whether they came back. Once a week, look for three things: cards that weren’t entered by Monday, guests whose next step is overdue, and guests who reached Day 21 without being introduced to anyone.

  • Get permission before you text. The wireless industry’s guidelines expect people to agree to texts for a specific purpose when they give their number, and they count welcome texts as that kind of message.
  • Say who’s texting and how to stop. Honor STOP, “unsubscribe” or “please stop” the first time. Industry guidance asks senders to confirm an opt-out once and then not send anything else.
  • Don’t add guests to a mailing list they didn’t ask for. A follow-up email from a person isn’t the same as signing them up for the weekly newsletter.
  • Use one channel at a time. A text, an email and a phone call on the same day can feel like you’re chasing them.
  • Know when to stop. After the Day 14–21 message, don’t send anything else unless they reply.
  • Keep prayer requests private. Share them only with the pastor or prayer team. Never put them in a group email, and never quote them back in an automated message.

How this works in Sanctuary

If you use Sanctuary, every church starts with two regular Core forms, Plan Your Visit and First Time Visitor, and you can edit them like any other form. Public forms don’t need a sign-in. When someone fills one in, Sanctuary updates their profile if the email matches someone you already have, or creates a new profile if it doesn’t. If it isn’t sure about a match, it flags it for an admin to review instead of merging them automatically. A form can give new profiles a membership type like Visitor, notify specific staff members, and create a follow-up task for a person you choose every time someone submits it.

A form can also ask for permission to text. When someone checks the box, Sanctuary records their consent along with the exact wording they agreed to. Texts go out from your church’s own toll-free number, and if someone texts STOP, that number won’t text them again. A sheet can turn your guests into a live list, like “filled in the First Time Visitor card in the last 30 days.” A sheet automation can create a task or send a fixed email you wrote yourself when someone joins that list. Automations never act on the people who were already on the sheet when you turn them on, and they pause if a large batch is suddenly due.

On plans that include Shepherd, the guest follow-up agent drafts a welcome text and email for each new card within minutes. It uses what the guest checked, and adds a line for whoever is reviewing it about what the guest asked for. Nothing goes to the guest until a staff member reads it, edits it if they want, and taps Send. They can also skip it or hand it to someone else as a task. The model is only told that a prayer request exists, never what it says, so it can’t quote it.

What software can’t do for you

No software can make a guest feel known. Templates, tasks and drafts just free up time for the part that matters, which is someone remembering their name next Sunday. If nobody at your church has time to write the midweek note, sort that out before you buy anything.

  • Most churches don’t take attendance for adults, so a “we missed you” message usually depends on a host noticing someone’s been gone. In Sanctuary, check-in history only helps if you use Check-Ins, which is in early access, and we set it up with each church.
  • Sanctuary’s drafts are a starting point. They can be bland, and they’re only as accurate as the card. Read every one before you send it.
  • Texting needs a carrier-verified number and paid message credits. If your church won’t keep texting consent up to date, email and a handwritten card are better than texts.
  • This guide isn’t legal advice. If your church sends promotional texts, or sends a lot of texts, ask someone qualified about the rules that apply to you.

Sources

CTIA, Messaging Principles and Best Practices (May 2023), sections 5.1 to 5.1.5 on consent, opt-in records and opt-out, api.ctia.org.

See how Sanctuary keeps the work connected

Sanctuary keeps people, serving and giving on the same record. Core is free, with no limit on how many people you keep in it.