Church giving
How to choose online giving for your church, and what the fees really cost
Almost every giving platform takes cards and recurring gifts. The real differences are how they charge you, whose account the money goes into, and what you can take with you if you leave. This guide explains the fees and gives you questions to ask before you sign.
What should you compare?
It mostly comes down to four questions. What will each gift actually cost, given the kinds of gifts your church gets? Whose account does the money go into? Can donors give the way they already pay for things? And what can you take with you if you leave? The differences that cost churches money are usually in the pricing and the fine print. The feature lists tend to look alike.
This guide is about picking a provider. For setting up funds, following up on recurring gifts that have stopped, and getting ready for January, see our church online giving guide.
How processing fees work for cards, bank transfers and wallets
Every online gift goes through a payment processor, and the processor charges a fee no matter which giving platform you use. How it’s worked out depends on how the donor pays.
- Cards. Usually a percentage of the gift plus a small flat amount per transaction. For example, Stripe’s published standard US rate for a domestic card is 2.9% plus 30 cents, and international cards cost an extra 1.5%.
- Bank transfers (ACH). Usually much cheaper, often a small percentage with a cap. Stripe’s standard ACH Direct Debit rate is 0.8%, capped at $5. Checking a donor’s bank account instantly can cost extra. Stripe lists $1.50 per successful instant verification. Verifying with microdeposits is free.
- Wallets. Apple Pay and Google Pay run on the donor’s card, so they’re generally priced like card payments. Stripe lists them under the same rate as cards. They’re worth offering because they make giving on a phone quick. They don’t cost any less.
That has two effects. First, the flat amount per transaction makes small gifts expensive for their size. At Stripe’s standard card rate, a $10 gift costs 59 cents to process, which is nearly 6%. A $100 gift costs $3.20. Four weekly $10 gifts cost $2.36 a month in fees, while one $40 monthly gift costs $1.46. Second, bank transfers are much cheaper on large gifts. A $1,000 card gift costs $29.30. The same gift by ACH costs $5.
It doesn’t always work out that way, though. On a small gift from a bank account the donor just linked, the verification charge can make the bank gift cost more than a card would. Bank gifts also take a few days to clear.
Platform fees, processing fees and percentage-of-giving pricing
The platform fee is a separate cost, and it’s where vendors differ the most. It goes to the software company, not the card networks. It might be a subscription, a charge on each gift on top of processing, or built into one combined percentage.
Be careful with percentage-of-giving pricing. One combined rate looks simple, but your cost goes up as your church gives more, even if you use the software exactly the same. A strong December or one large estate gift means a bigger bill that month for the same software. Work it out using your actual yearly total, including your largest gifts. Then compare it with what processing alone would cost at the processor’s published rate. The difference is what you’re paying the platform.
Also ask whether bank gifts are charged at the bank rate or the combined rate. If ACH gifts are charged a card-like percentage, there’s not much reason left to encourage donors to use them.
| Pricing model | How the church pays | Works well when | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Processing passed through, software by subscription | The processor’s rate on each gift, plus a flat monthly or yearly software fee | Giving is steady or growing and you want costs that don’t go up when people give more | You still pay the subscription in a slow month. Check what each tier includes. |
| Processing passed through, no platform fee on gifts | Only the processor’s rate on each gift. The software is paid for some other way. | You want the lowest cost per gift and can see the processor’s own statements | How the vendor gets paid instead, and whether that could change later |
| Combined percentage of giving | One rate per gift that covers processing and the platform’s margin | Giving is small and you don’t want a fixed monthly cost | Cost goes up with every large gift and every good year. Bank gifts may be priced like cards. |
| Platform fee per gift, on top of processing | The processor’s rate plus a platform charge on every transaction | Your giving comes in a small number of large gifts | Small weekly gifts and text gifts cost a lot for their size |
| Donor-funded, "free to the church" | Donors are asked to add a fee or a tip when they give | The church can’t carry any cost at all | What happens when donors say no, and whether the ask gets in the way of someone giving |
Any of these can be the right choice. Work out what each one would cost you in your biggest giving month, and make sure you’re OK with that number.
Letting donors cover the fee
Many platforms let a donor add the processing fee to their gift so the church gets the full amount. A few details make a difference:
- Make it optional, and word it as an offer. It shouldn’t sound like you’re correcting them.
- Work it out on the total. The processor takes its percentage from the whole charge, including what the donor added. So if you add exactly 2.9% plus 30 cents to a $100 gift, the church ends up a few cents short. At that rate the right amount to add is $3.30, not $3.20.
- Price it for the payment method. A bank gift’s fee isn’t the same as a card’s, and a donor choosing between them should be able to see the difference.
- Ask how the covered amount shows up on the donor’s year-end statement, and check how to treat it with your own tax advisor.
Who holds the money, and when it reaches your bank
Ask two simple questions. Whose account does a gift go into? And when does it reach your bank?
Some platforms collect gifts into an account they control and pay churches out on their own schedule. Others make each charge on a processor account that belongs to your church, so the platform never holds the money. If the money sits with the platform, their rules on holds and timing apply to your gifts, and if you leave you’ll have to wait for a final payout. If the account is yours, you can see every charge, refund and payout in your own dashboard. You’re also the one who keeps its verification and bank details up to date.
Payout timing is usually set by the processor. Stripe, for example, can pay out on a rolling basis, weekly or monthly. Ask which schedule you’d be on and how a payout matches up with the gifts in it. Your treasurer reconciles deposits every week. If a payout can’t be traced back to its gifts, that costs volunteer hours every time.
Ask about disputes too. When a donor disputes a charge with their bank, the processor usually charges a fee. Stripe lists $15 per dispute received. Find out who pays it.
Recurring gifts, text giving and leaving
Recurring gifts are the most valuable part of online giving, and they’re the hardest to move. The card or bank details behind them are held by the processor. They aren’t in a spreadsheet you can export. Before you sign, ask what happens to every recurring gift if you leave. Can the payment details move with you, or would each giver have to set their gift up again? It’s better to find out now than when you’re in the middle of switching.
Text giving is worth having if your church will actually promote it. Ask how someone texting for the first time finishes setting up, whether the number belongs to your church, what it costs each month, and how texting consent is handled. Check that a text gift ends up on the same donor record as that person’s card gifts.
For data, ask for an export during the demo and open it. You want every gift with its date, amount, fund, payment method and a donor ID that doesn’t change. You also want the funds themselves and the recurring schedules. A list of totals per donor isn’t your giving history. Our guide to questions to ask during a church management software demo goes into exports in more detail.
Questions to ask a giving vendor
Bring these to the demo, and get the answers about money in writing:
- 1What is the total cost per gift for the kinds of gifts we get: card, bank and wallet, small weekly gifts and large yearly ones?
- 2Is there a platform fee on top of processing? Is it per gift, monthly, or built into one rate?
- 3Are bank (ACH) gifts charged at the bank rate or at the card rate?
- 4Whose account does a gift go into, and who is the merchant of record?
- 5When do payouts reach our bank, and can we match each payout to its gifts?
- 6Who pays dispute fees, and how is a refund recorded?
- 7Can donors cover the fee, and is it worked out for their payment method?
- 8Can donors give weekly or monthly, manage their own recurring gift, and hear from us when a card fails?
- 9How does text giving work for someone giving for the first time, and what does the number cost?
- 10Does each gift attach to the same person record as the rest of our church data?
- 11Can we export every gift, fund and recurring schedule? What happens to recurring gifts if we leave?
- 12Is there a contract term or a cancellation fee?
Where Sanctuary Give fits
Sanctuary Give uses the second model in the table. Your church connects its own Stripe account. It’s a full account that you own and sign in to, and every gift is a charge on that account, with your church as the merchant of record. Gifts go from Stripe to your bank on your Stripe payout schedule. Sanctuary never holds the money and doesn’t take a cut of any gift. Stripe charges its own processing fees. Give is part of Sanctuary’s paid plans. Core, the people database underneath it, is free.
Donors can give by card, by Apple Pay or Google Pay if their device supports it, or by US bank transfer once ACH is turned on in your Stripe dashboard. They can give once, weekly or monthly, and they can choose to cover the fee. The amount they add is worked out on the total for the payment method they pick, including the one-time charge for linking a new bank account. Text giving runs on a number your church rents. Every gift is attached to a person in Core, the same record that has their family, forms and serving.
If you leave, Give’s reports export to CSV with every gift in the date range. If you’re moving to Sanctuary, your recurring gifts come over as invitations, not as schedules. Nothing is charged until each giver adds a card or bank account through their link. The new gift starts on their next date from the old system, so nobody gets charged twice in one cycle.
When Sanctuary Give isn’t the right fit
Sanctuary Give only works with Stripe. If your church has a processor it wants to keep, or a negotiated rate somewhere else, that’s a good reason to look at other options.
Owning the account protects you, but it also means more for you to look after. Stripe’s verification, any documents it asks for and the bank details on file are yours to keep up to date. Sanctuary support can see whether your account is connected and taking charges, and we’ll help you work through a problem, but the account is yours.
Pass-through pricing isn’t always the cheapest either. If you already have a low negotiated card rate, or you’d rather pay one percentage than any monthly bill, another model might suit you better. Take last year’s gifts, by size and payment method, and run them through each vendor’s published rates.
Sources
Stripe, Pricing & fees, standard US pricing for cards and wallets, ACH Direct Debit, instant bank verification, disputes and payouts, stripe.com/pricing (opened November 15, 2026).
See how Sanctuary keeps the work connected
Sanctuary keeps people, serving and giving on the same record. Core is free, with no limit on how many people you keep in it.